India, the world’s largest democracy, has a complex and multifaceted record when it comes to honouring human rights. Its constitution, adopted in 1950, guarantees a wide range of fundamental rights to all citizens, reflecting a commitment to justice, equality, and freedom. These rights, including freedom of speech, right to education, and right to life and personal liberty, are enshrined in Part III of the Indian Constitution. India is also a signatory to various international human rights conventions, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). However, despite these formal commitments, India’s human rights record has been a subject of both domestic debate and international scrutiny due to challenges in implementation, political considerations, and regional conflicts.
1. Constitutional and Legal Framework
India’s commitment to human rights is enshrined in its Constitution, which guarantees rights such as:
- Article 14: Equality before the law.
- Article 19: Freedom of speech and expression.
- Article 21: Right to life and personal liberty.
- Article 25–28: Right to freedom of religion.
These rights are intended to protect citizens from discrimination and ensure personal and political freedoms. Additionally, India has a robust legal system with mechanisms for judicial review to protect human rights. The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), established in 1993, is another critical institution aimed at addressing human rights violations.
(a) Judiciary and Human Rights Protection
- The Indian judiciary has played a crucial role in upholding human rights, often intervening in matters of public interest. Landmark judgments, such as the Right to Privacy (2017), have strengthened human rights protection. Additionally, the right to education was judicially recognized as a fundamental right in the Right to Education Act (2009).
2. Human Rights Challenges in India
Despite the strong constitutional framework, India faces several challenges in effectively ensuring human rights across its vast and diverse population. Some of the key issues are:
(a) Freedom of Expression and Press Freedom
- India has faced growing concerns about freedom of speech, particularly in the context of press freedom. While the Constitution guarantees freedom of expression, India ranks low in global press freedom indices, with numerous reports of intimidation and violence against journalists.
- The 2019 amendment to the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), which has been used to suppress dissent, has drawn widespread criticism for infringing on civil liberties. The disappearance of journalists and the arrest of activists are also areas of concern.
(b) Religious and Caste-Based Discrimination
- India’s large and diverse society faces persistent challenges with religious intolerance and caste-based discrimination. While the Constitution outlaws untouchability and caste-based discrimination, incidents of violence against Dalits and Muslims continue to occur, particularly in rural areas.
- The 2019 Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), which grants citizenship to non-Muslim refugees from neighboring countries, has been seen by many as discriminatory and has sparked widespread protests, raising concerns about the protection of minority rights.
Vocabulary Tip: Dissent refers to the expression of opinions that are different from or opposed to the prevailing views or policies.
(c) Religious Freedom and Violence
- India’s secular status is often challenged by incidents of religious violence. Communal riots and attacks on religious minorities, including Muslims and Christians, have raised questions about the state’s ability to protect its citizens’ religious freedom.
- The 2013 Muzaffarnagar riots and incidents in Kashmir have highlighted issues related to religious and ethnic tensions.
(d) Human Rights in Jammu and Kashmir
- The region of Jammu and Kashmir has been the focal point of human rights concerns, particularly since the revocation of Article 370 in August 2019, which led to increased military presence and restrictions on movement, communication, and political activities.
- Reports of human rights abuses by security forces, including extrajudicial killings, torture, and arbitrary detentions, have drawn both domestic and international criticism. The situation in Kashmir remains one of the most significant challenges to India’s human rights record.
(e) Freedom of Assembly and Right to Protest
- The right to protest has been a fundamental aspect of India’s democracy. However, protests against government policies—such as those related to agricultural reforms in 2020–21—have often been met with violence and repression. The use of force against peaceful protestors, as seen in the farmers’ protests, has been widely condemned by human rights organizations.
3. India’s Role in International Human Rights
(a) Commitment to International Human Rights Framework
- India has consistently supported the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and has ratified major international human rights instruments, including the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR).
- India has also played a role in global forums such as the UN Human Rights Council, where it advocates for a balanced and culturally sensitive approach to human rights, focusing on poverty alleviation, economic development, and social equity.
(b) Challenges with International Scrutiny
- India’s human rights record has faced criticism from international organizations like Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, especially regarding issues such as the death penalty, freedom of expression, and the situation in Kashmir.
- However, India has often rejected external criticism, asserting its sovereignty and the need for cultural contextualization of human rights, emphasizing the importance of economic development and poverty reduction as fundamental rights.
4. Conclusion
India’s record in honouring human rights is characterised by a combination of progressive legal frameworks and serious challenges in implementation. While the Constitution guarantees a wide range of rights and India has made strides in sectors like education and healthcare, issues such as religious intolerance, caste-based discrimination, and regional security concerns continue to pose significant barriers. India’s human rights record requires continuous attention to ensure the protection of vulnerable groups and to uphold the principles of equality and justice enshrined in its Constitution. The evolving role of India on the global human rights stage highlights the complexities of balancing national interests with international human rights obligations.
Leave a Reply