St. Augustine of Hippo (354–430 CE), a towering figure in early Christian philosophy and theology, played a crucial role in shaping the political thought of the medieval world. His most significant political ideas are encapsulated in his magnum opus The City of God (De Civitate Dei), written between 413 and 426 CE. In this work, Augustine responds to the collapse of the Roman Empire and offers a theologically grounded interpretation of history, politics, and human society. Augustine’s political philosophy represents a shift from classical Greco-Roman secular rationalism to a faith-oriented Christian worldview, making him a foundational thinker in Western Christian political thought.
1. Dualism of the Two Cities: City of God and City of Man
One of the most distinctive features of Augustine’s political thought is his theory of the Two Cities:
- The City of God (Civitas Dei):
- Composed of those who live according to the will of God.
- It is guided by the virtue of love (caritas) and aimed at eternal peace.
- Citizens of this city prioritize spiritual goals and divine justice.
- Ultimately, this city is not of the earth but is a heavenly city, attainable only after death.
- The City of Man (Civitas Terrena):
- Constituted by those who live according to the flesh and seek worldly pleasures, power, and wealth.
- Guided by self-love (amor sui), pride, and the desire to dominate.
- It is temporary, flawed, and filled with conflict and injustice.
Augustine wrote: “Two loves have made two cities: the love of God made the City of God; the love of self made the earthly city.”
This dichotomy is not strictly political versus religious, but moral and spiritual. The two cities can coexist in this world, and individuals may belong to both temporarily, but they represent fundamentally different allegiances.
2. Nature and Role of the State
Augustine viewed the state not as a natural institution (as Aristotle did), but as a consequence of sin.
- After the Fall of Man (original sin), human beings lost their innate harmony and justice. The result was disorder, violence, and the need for coercion.
- The state emerges as a necessary evil, instituted to maintain order in a fallen world.
- It uses force and law to restrain sinful behavior and preserve peace.
Augustine wrote: “Justice being taken away, then, what are kingdoms but great robberies?”
Thus, a state that does not follow divine justice is morally deficient, even if it is powerful.
3. Justice and Political Authority
For Augustine, true justice is rooted in God. A state that does not acknowledge God cannot be truly just.
- He emphasized the divine origin of law and authority.
- Civil laws are to be obeyed as long as they do not contradict divine commandments.
- However, obedience to God takes precedence over obedience to the state.
This provides a basis for moral resistance to unjust rule — a concept that influenced later Christian and liberal thought.
4. Augustine on History and Providence
Augustine introduced a providential view of history, rejecting the classical cyclical model of the Greeks and Romans.
- History is linear and purposeful, moving towards a divine end.
- Events (such as the fall of Rome) are not to be understood in purely political or military terms, but as part of God’s overarching plan.
- The ultimate victory of the City of God is predestined and not dependent on earthly political arrangements.
This theological historicism had a profound impact on medieval and early modern historiography and political theory.
5. Augustine on Property and Slavery
A. Property:
- Augustine did not treat private property as a natural right (as Locke would later do).
- He accepted its existence as a social institution that must be regulated by Christian ethics, especially charity and stewardship.
- He emphasized that true ownership belongs to God.
B. Slavery:
- Augustine saw slavery as a result of human sin.
- It was not a natural condition (unlike Aristotle), but a punishment for the fallen nature of man.
- Though he did not call for its abolition, he encouraged humane treatment and spiritual equality of slaves.
6. Influence and Legacy
Augustine’s ideas formed the theological and political bedrock of medieval Christendom. His legacy includes:
- A Christian vision of political order that stresses moral limits on state power.
- A justification for the separation of spiritual and temporal realms, paving the way for debates on church and state.
- The groundwork for Christian just war theory, later developed by thinkers like St. Thomas Aquinas.
- Profound influence on thinkers such as Dante, Luther, Calvin, and even modern philosophers like Hannah Arendt.
7. Criticism of Augustine’s Political Thought
- Theocratic Overtones: Critics argue that Augustine’s political theology could justify religious authoritarianism.
- Neglect of Political Autonomy: By emphasizing the divine over the temporal, Augustine diminished the role of human agency in politics.
- Pessimistic View of Human Nature: His vision assumes a deeply flawed humanity, which some argue underestimates the potential for human progress.
Conclusion
St. Augustine’s political thought represents a synthesis of Christian theology and classical philosophy, rooted in a deep moral and metaphysical understanding of human nature and history. His theory of the Two Cities, critique of worldly power, and emphasis on divine justice continue to resonate in theological, philosophical, and political discourse. Augustine’s political thought is less concerned with institutional design and more focused on spiritual ends, offering a profound vision of politics in a world marked by sin, conflict, and the hope of redemption.
Leave a Reply